There Should Be No Guilt or Shame Attached To Being Charitable

76

By markbennis

Are we being led astray from our free choice of being charitable and kindness to others that are suffering in the world around us?

There has been a growing trend of distasteful and forceful strategies being played on the hearts and minds of the ordinary public for many years now, a strategic mix of psychological and emotional manipulation to render monies from you to causes and charities that well, seem just to be doing the same thing year after year, with no real outcome.

I mean and I will now say that not all charities are being judged by my own humble opinion here but more to do with the moral issues that are now curdling up from within society.

I am really expressing from a detached view point for what I myself am feeling lately and also from the mumblings of others so I will jump back to timeline 1 and continue in the manner I began.


The Negative Strategy Is Destroying the Real Essence of Charity

We have been bombarded constantly via the mainstream media and other angles too, with what I consider a campaign that is far from allowing you a free choice of being charitable on your own accord or terms, you are simply being manipulated by negative strategies that prey on your fears and guilt’s.

This sickening betrayal and deceptive line of advertisement has got me thinking to what end will they go too, just to get money from you and in the end you really never know of its impact or justified outcome.

It is my humble opinion that this strategy of negative manipulation of people’s emotions has eroded the true essence of the meaning of charity and has also damaged its great intent.

I now am seeing an aggressive type of charity collectors that are pouncing on the public everywhere we go; even when we finally get home I am seeing it being played out in a long and draining commercial that is praying on your emotions and in a very negative way, with guilt, shame, fear and disgust!


This Negative Manipulation Has Filtered Into the Psychology

I now see often the reactions of people changing to charity collectors and more in defiance of this negative intrusion, people are growing sick of it! People are growing weary and agonised by seeing a charity commercial as it plays deeply on your guilt and shaming emotions.

People are now responding to these commercialised charity organisations with negative and thoughts of conspiracy, like they have been showing that advert for years so where is all the money going, why have we not seen some change there etc, etc.

This growing dislike is filtering psychologically onto the streets and into our communities, where we see a homeless person looking for a bit of change now they are being ignored and judged, “ oh he will only buy alcohol with it or drugs” some might say or “ I am sick of giving money to no good causes”.

I really believe ‘Charity’ is being destroyed and cleverly too, it’s a dark assumption but I don’t see that love and hope of charity in the eyes and actions of people anymore, they almost feel it’s another way for these big corporations to make some easy money.

Cynicism is growing strife on the streets and in all honesty who can blame them, the governments of the world are taxing people to death, cameras everywhere and fines for this and fines for that, like gangsters that are ripping off the ordinary people and sucking them dry.


A Sad Example of Charity Being Destroyed!

A dear friend of mine was busy shopping with her mother the other day and when she went to put away her shopping in the car, a man approached and obviously spoke little English as he conversed to her via sign language, gesturing if he could have some food or money for.

Obviously she was a bit daunted by the surprise of it all and gesture to him saying no, but he again gestured back in a way that he would return her trolley, now obviously for the £1.00 coin that it had within it.

Again she gestured to him no and go away, fair enough I thought you were busy and was caught of guard a little, but she didn't feel right!

She began to explain that although he looked pretty clean and she couldn't immediately tell if he was a homeless person but that more importantly, she didn't know what to do?

I said to her what did you feel in your heart that you should have done? She said I should have at least been charitable and let him take the trolley so he could have the £1.00 coin, but she felt guilty because she didn't.

I said you don’t need to feel guilty because charity is giving from the heart without judgment, there is no obligation to do so, it’s more of an act of kindness that has no judgment or negative conditions to it, and it’s simply from your heart.

I thought to myself sometime after and realised that we the ordinary people are becoming very confused what it really means to be charitable. There is a reversal in its real essence and now unfortunately there seems to be a stigma of guilt and shame for not giving, that’s not right I thought and then started to notice more of this negative association playing out in front of my eyes.

It’s not that people are just becoming more selfish or just unkind, but more of a negative programming that has filtered its way into our psychology somehow, that has taken away our right to just do what is in our hearts free from guilt and all negative stigmas, such a shame.


What is Charity Really?

Simply to me, being charitable is an act of kindness that is enacted by you from your own free choice with no thought and no judgment, just an act of love from the heart.

Charity is about giving and not receiving and it can only be an act of charity if you give from the heart where that kind act comes from, a non judgmental affection for the better good.

Charity is kindness and comes from the heart, it is not something that should be forced on anyone but just a gracious act of kindness on behalf of the person, I shall be charitable because it is my choice to do so, because it is something I wish to do from my heart.

What Charity Is Not!

Charity is not a virtue that calls to you through guilt, shame, fear or because someone has made you feel you have too. It is not a reason to manipulate you via negative influence that infringes on your own free will and limit you into giving monies over to another person or organisation.


Example of Charity at Work

I had walked to the shops with my little daughter who is 4 years old and we were about to go into one shop and I had noticed a young lady sitting on the cold floor asking for some change.

I had noticed the familiar pattern evolving in front of my eyes as people avoided eye contact with her, as I came back out of one shop I gave my little girl a £2.00 coin and gestured to her to give that to the lady sitting on the floor over there.

She hesitated a moment and a little confuse but I gave her that loving smile to reassure her that it was OK to do so, she did and the lady was grateful and thanked her, then I took hold of her hand and we crossed the road to go back home.

I had noticed my little girl kept looking back at her, I guess trying to figure out what that was all about and why I had done that, also probably who was that lady too.

I didn’t feel I had to explain because she did not ask and most importantly that an act of kindness is recognised by us all, you don’t need to explain what you just did or seen, you simply sense it.

If you are judgmental you may think that I just wasted £2.00 of my own money and that she is probably going to use it for drugs or alcohol, she might? Then she might not?

But you have just forgotten what being charitable means, that you first do what is in your heart, it’s an act of kindness created from the all wise and loving part of your heart, you gave willingly and without question nor judgment, this is the part of you that is really you. For I never felt guilty or ashamed for doing it, in fact that act of kindness had made me feel good in my heart, made me feel human.


Charity Is Simply an Act of kindness

Charity is simply an act of kindness that we feel in our hearts to do, its this act of kindness that truly makes us human, for we can lend a hand to a fellow human or animal and offer help or assistance without condition nor judgment.

There should be no feelings of guilt, shame nor disgust attached to charity and certainly should not be a cunning motive to manipulate people in handing over money.

If you feel that you do not wish to be charitable then that is your choice, you should not have to feel any negative emotional affliction because of it.

The point I am trying to get to is this, that we should not allow ourselves to be cleverly misdirected or influenced by negative design; you simply wouldn't fall in love with someone that made you feel guilty, shameful and disgusted with yourself would you?

Then you should never hand money over to anybody or an organisation that coerced you into giving by negative means of guilt, shame or disgust. That is why there is a negative stigma to charity and to being charitable; people are forgetting what it is simply to be charitable because if this misuse of the term.

It simply needs to be rectified in my opinion and brought back into its true understanding, Charity is simply that kind act of giving or helping, that is truly from the heart, no judgment nor negative attachment.


To The So Called Charities

If you are a charity collector or a charity that is spending thousands upon thousands of pounds/dollars from the money that charitable people has donated on shameful and ignorant advertisement, that preys on the negative emotions that can account to blackmail really, then I will tell you now, that your organisation has nothing to do with charity one bit!

How dare you spend the money that people have graciously donated on sick twisted manipulating advertisements making people feel guilty, shameful and disgusted because your immoral tactic is to prey on those aspects and gain monies from them?

How dare you call yourselves charities when you have no moral code to even understand the true meaning of the word?

You false Organisations that prey on the psychology of the public but in essence misdirect and falsely use the word charity and in doing so have tried to plague guilt and shame on them, you have brought the essence of charity into a despised depth that is now effecting the works of being charitable as the public are being misguided by your greed and misuse for your riches.

You will never destroy Charity as it is a virtue of being human and I hope this article sheds light on a much needed situation.

Comments

Larry Wall profile image

Larry Wall Level 6 Commenter 3 months ago

This is an excellent hub. No one should ever give out of guilt. In my family (immediate and extended) we cover diabetes, breast cancer, heart disease, mental health and a few others. We have rescued two dogs. We do most of our giving through our church and church related organizations.

I do not give to charities that spend more money trying to collect money from me after I have already declined.

I seldom give money on the street to anyone, but I have made exceptions.

There are many worthwhile charities, but no one person can give to all of them and have the contribution still be of any value.

If you see a child in a store trying to collect money for her family, call 911, they will get the proper help for her.

Those of us who have been bless with health, good jobs, good families and lot of other good fortunes should be willing to help others, but only because it is the right thing to do and it should never be done out of guilt and too many organizations play on guilt.

This was an excellent hub and I am now a new follower.

markbennis profile image

markbennis Hub Author 3 months ago

Hello Larry Wall,

Let me say thank you for posting and sharing your experiences also valued opinions too, I feel it’s important to try and restore the true virtues of being charitable and what it means, its time to shed some light on these terrible tactics being used like guilt, shame etc.

Which I feel is destroying the fundamental principles and affecting the work of all those good people that themselves are the perfect example for being charitable.

Thanks again, all the best, Mark.

alocsin profile image

alocsin Level 8 Commenter 3 months ago

I think if you remember that charity is just an act of kindness, instead of some big complicated action, you won't have any guilt or shame to it. Voting this Up and Interesting.

markbennis profile image

markbennis Hub Author 3 months ago

Yes and nicely said alocsin also thanks for posting, all the best, mark

sabrina bennis 3 months ago

well done you have completly shocked me, your brilliant well done xx

markbennis profile image

markbennis Hub Author 3 months ago

Thanks Sabrina x

PHILLYDREAMER profile image

PHILLYDREAMER Level 3 Commenter 3 months ago

I like the statement you made here, but I think some people just naturally feel guilty. I know there are plenty of times where I have a little extra to give, but I when I choose to ignore this knowledge, it just doesn't feel right to me. I also wonder where money goes when you donate to organizations. I wanted to start some kind of charity drive through an online radio show I use to do, but I couldn't get a straight answer from organizations as to where the money was going to go. I wanted to promote a charity that would help homeless people by getting them situated in homes and give them the chance to rebuild their lives. There were plenty people who were willing to receive donations, but there was no clear cut agenda fo the money.

markbennis profile image

markbennis Hub Author 3 months ago

Hello PHILLYDREAMER,

Thanks for posting and you have raised some serious issues that need to be more transparent, why don’t some of these so called Charities share that information?

They are quick to take the money as you rightly said, maybe you should set up a website that is aimed for the homeless agenda and ask for donations that way, you may not be a registered Charity but, by being transparent with what you are doing you may find people will feel your cause is more genuine.

I don’t know about you but I do wonder sometimes where all this money goes? What is really being achieved and how much of a result is accomplished?

But more in line with my message too is why are they using negative advertisement to swing your emotions through fear, guilt and shamefulness just to make you feel like real crap, so you hand over money to something you will never hear about again until there next advertisement campaign.

Why are they being let do it as well is another point I would like to make and look at the fate of all those negative and repulsive, manipulating advertisements that cost in excess of thousands of pounds that has been raised by good people.

What is resonating from the street level is one of mistrust and conspiracy these massive organisations are playing a dangerous game that is in turn branding Charity as a waste of time and money, let alone degrading the true essence of Charity as a whole.

I don’t know about you but I smell a rat! Something is quite not right with this agenda of there’s and how they are going about it!

John Sarkis profile image

John Sarkis Level 7 Commenter 3 months ago

Very powerful hub Mark - so true! Our society makes us feel if we give and/or are nice to people that it's somehow a form of weakness. If we're mean and abrupt, then this is the way to be. You make some great points in you article which I found interesting and voted as such.

Take care

John

markbennis profile image

markbennis Hub Author 3 months ago

Hello John,

Thanks for posting and yes you are absolutely right because people seem to be programmed to remain in that oppositional state of psychology, they would now rather walk past that mother struggling with a pram up the stairs, even cross to the other side of the street so they can avoid the tramp asking for a bit of change?

I personally feel like society is being programmed in such a way that they are becoming very detached from there hearts and humanistic behaviours, just my opinion of course but in the end no matter how much bad influences are around us, it ultimately is our own responsibility.

Take care John and thanks again, Mark.

nityanandagaurang profile image

nityanandagaurang 3 months ago

When you give charity to someone ,it gives you inner satisfaction that can't be comapared.We should promote it as it brings good aspect of ours.Very interesting hub markbennis.Voted up and shared.

markbennis profile image

markbennis Hub Author 3 months ago

Thank you for promoting the positive aspects of what Charity really is; it is in its true essence a gracious act of unconditional love, direct from our hearts.

Thanks again nityanandagaurang and all the best, Mark.

benbaligad profile image

benbaligad 3 months ago

Why people give and why people will not give is a mystery to me. Perhaps, that is where we, who have charitable organizations should look at and I myself has not looked at.

I remember about a dozen years back when I had my computer a few years and was member of a forum whose members are from a poor section out of the Philippines. I decided how great it would be if their library had their own computer. There was only one other there then, shared by many.

The computer was $550, including shipping. There were many forum members whom I made friend with. I thought for sure, I can raise that much. After a month of posting almost daily, I ended giving half of it.

Now that I just learned how to make a website, I ran into a girl who really needs to be helped. She needs surgery to save her life. She is getting a small, steady stream of donations, but she needs the surgery ASAP. I decided to put up a site for her. I have not gotten a single cent after two months.

I recently joined a web review group where websites are given to others and are given a review. Out of 24 times my site was presented, there was 5 clicks, 1 review and 18 skips.

http://savingbeautifulpeople.com

I don't know if this comment is counted as promoting my site and is against the rules. I apologize if that is the case.

markbennis profile image

markbennis Hub Author 3 months ago

Hello benbaligad,

You seem a very nice guy and what you are attempting is very amicable and I wish you luck and success.

I had a look at your Website and although your intentions are all good but I did not feel over whelmed when I landed on your front page, this could be for a number of reasons and I can only share my opinion,

Firstly it’s important to break down the barrier of the artificial interface which is the internet, I mean I don’t really know her personally so it would be better to have a whole page that focuses on an individual or a cause that is focused on one thing.

You get around on average up to 10 seconds to grab hold of a viewer and make an impact via the internet and I was a bit confused ‘what were what’ and what it was exactly for, plus the mix of Russian distracted me because I don’t know how to read Russian.

Ref to Liana: Also because you had sent it to me personally I had stayed longer then I would have if I had just stumbled upon it via just browsing, so I was put off more when there was a long and complicated way of donating, i.e. Western Union and then having to e-mail her too, better to have one big donate button and allow the website to do all the fiddly bits, that’s just me.

I think you should start an open forum here on Hubpages with regards to your site/cause and ask for a ‘critique’ I believe as a fellow Huber you will be surprised at the level of help and advice you may get, there is a vast pool of knowledge here at Hubpages and you never know who maybe is just under the radar in our own community, you might just meet people that are doing the same as you?

Worth a try don’t you think? Why not write a Hub about it you are allowed I believe up to 3 external links in one Hub but you can check that out in the Hubpages Facts Section?

I wish you luck and all the best, mark.

Swinging back on topic to this article I guess you may of highlighted a very real boundary, people are more inclined to feel into a cause if they feel it is real, I mean for instance when something is localised like helping the homeless in your local area you feel more inclined to help, plus you will always receive a real time update of that cause, I guess it may make you feel apart of it more especially when you are seeing change and hearing about it from your community, I believe this breaks down the barriers and detachment from participating, again this is my own humbled opinion.

Much to learn about all this and I guess by communicating and sharing our own opinions that’s how we can improve and bridge the gap?

I am for the true spirit that is Charity and would like to see more people like benbaligad get more support and would like for the bigger organisations that are using negative means to learn a lesson, they are putting people off and making them turn away, creating mistrust and destroying the good faith that charity was founded on.

benbaligad profile image

benbaligad 3 months ago

Thanks, Mark. I will look into your suggestions individually. I was thinking of separating the Russian part into another website. The Russian part is probably a big barrier.

Paypal is the best way to donate. I have paypal links. I had Paypal icons that linked, but when I read the ebay affiliate TOS, they did not like it. They rejected me anyway even without them, without giving specific reasons, so I'll put them back.

One thing that makes me apprehensive is Hubpages TOS. Is this promoting a website which is against Hubpages TOS? I guess that is one thing to put in the forum.

markbennis profile image

markbennis Hub Author 3 months ago

Hello benbaligad,

I think it would be a fantastic idea to run this through the Hubpages forum, that way you will get a broader response with an in-depth layout of knowledge all in one place.

I know you are new here so I am more than willing to start one off for you? Or you could start one off for yourself, it’s a great community here and you will be well supported and looked after.

I know what you mean regards to starting a new site and trying to get to grips with what we can and can’t do? I myself still need to go back and double check at times too, so much information to absorb but you will find Hubpages a really friendly site that will guide you more than ban you if you know what I mean.

Let me know if you need my assistance and I will be more than happy to help you, anyway I can?

benbaligad profile image

benbaligad 3 months ago

Would you start a forum for me, Mark? That would be great. I very much would appreciate it.

markbennis profile image

markbennis Hub Author 3 months ago

It will be my pleasure benbaligad and I will pop over to your Hub after and post a link for you to find it. :)

phillippeengel profile image

phillippeengel Level 1 Commenter 3 months ago

Nicely written, Mark. Your points are well elucidated and you managed to intrigue me with your argument.

markbennis profile image

markbennis Hub Author 3 months ago

well thank you phillippeengel...

stessily profile image

stessily Level 8 Commenter 3 months ago

mark, Well presented and thought-filled. It's interesting to read of your personal motivation for tackling this topic and of the way in which you implement charity in your life.

A recurring theme in ongoing discussions with one of my closest friends is the heartlessness and coldness which are encountered so often in daily life, much of it seeming to be not only unnecessary but also totally superfluous. So in a way it does seem that people are being programmed to distance themselves from those who aren't part of their immediate, very closely drawn circles. He often quotes from Matthew 24:12: "Because of the increase of wickedness, the love of most will grow cold." (NIV-UK)["And because iniquity shall abound, the love of many shall wax cold." (KJV)]

You've made excellent points here. It isn't charitable to strong-arm someone into giving.:-(

Perhaps an interesting example of a feeling of guilt prompting charity in a good way is the story of the establishment of Plant A Row for the Hungry by Jeff Lowenfels, a lawyer who was haunted by his refusal to give a few dollars to a homeless man in the nation's capital, Washington DC, and ended up being inspired to start his famous program, which is now in effect in the U.S. and Canada, with offers for introducing it into other countries. My sister Deedee (Derdriu) told me this inspirational story and wrote a hub about it.

Kind regards, Stessily

markbennis profile image

markbennis Hub Author 3 months ago

Hello stessily,

Yes you have articulately put this into a whole new context that many can relate to and be educated by, including myself.

Also thank you for a wonderful example and a bit of important history with regards to ‘Plant A Row for the Hungry by Jeff Lowenfels’ it sounds interesting and one that I should try to learn more about.

Thanks for commenting.

scott 8 weeks ago

just watched an advert for save the children. Talk about trying to guilt you in to giving them money. absolutely shameful-

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working